Videos for Section 6.1


Real inner products are generalizations of the familiar dot product for ${\bf R}^3$ and ${\bf R}^2$. So before we launch into inner products in general, let's review the dot product.

By the Pythagorean Theorem, the length of a vector ${\bf x} = x_1 {\bf e_1} + x_2 {\bf e_2} + x_3 {\bf e_3}$ is $$|{\bf x}| =\sqrt{x_1^2 + x_2^2 + x_3^2}.$$ The dot product of two vectors ${\bf x}$ and ${\bf y}$ is defined to be $$ {\bf x} \cdot {\bf y} = |{\bf x}| \, |{\bf y}|\, \cos(\theta),$$ where $\theta$ is the angle between the two vectors. The motivation for this formula, and the use of dot products to get projections, is explained in the following video. (Note: This video was made for M408M, so the notation is slightly different than we are using in M346.)

It's not hard to show that the dot product has four useful properties:

  1. $(a {\bf x} + b{\bf y}) \cdot {\bf z} = a ({\bf x} \cdot {\bf z}) + b ({\bf y} \cdot {\bf z})$. That is, the dot product is a linear function of the first factor, when we hold the second factor fixed.
  2. ${\bf x} \cdot (a {\bf y} + b{\bf z}) = a ({\bf x} \cdot {\bf y}) + b ({\bf x} \cdot {\bf z})$. That is, the dot product is a linear function of the second factor, when we hold the first factor fixed.
  3. ${\bf x} \cdot {\bf y} = {\bf y} \cdot {\bf x}$. Unlike the cross product, the dot product is symmetric.
  4. If ${\bf x} \ne 0$, then ${\bf x} \cdot {\bf x} > 0$. This is called positivity. In fact, ${\bf x} \cdot {\bf x} = |{\bf x}|^2$, since the angle between ${\bf x}$ and itself is zero.
From these properties, we derive a very simple formula for the dot product. Since ${\bf e_i} \cdot {\bf e}_j$ equals 1 if $i=j$ and 0 if $i \ne j$ (insofar as $\cos(\theta)$ is either 1 or 0), we have \begin{eqnarray*} {\bf x} \cdot {\bf y} & = & (x_1 {\bf e_1} + x_2 {\bf e_2} + x_3 {\bf e_3}) \cdot (y_1 {\bf e_1} + y_2 {\bf e_2} + y_3 {\bf e_3}) \cr &=& \phantom{+} x_1 y_1 {\bf e_1} \cdot {\bf e_1} + x_1 y_2 {\bf e_1} \cdot {\bf e_2} + x_1 y_3 {\bf e_1} \cdot {\bf e_3} \cr && + x_2 y_1 {\bf e_2} \cdot {\bf e_1} + x_2 y_2 {\bf e_2} \cdot {\bf e_2} + x_2 y_3 {\bf e_1} \cdot {\bf e_3} \cr && + x_3 y_1 {\bf e_3} \cdot {\bf e_1} + x_3 y_2 {\bf e_3} \cdot {\bf e_2} + x_2 y_3 {\bf e_3} \cdot {\bf e_3} \cr & = & x_1 y_1 + x_2 y_2 + x_3 y_3. \end{eqnarray*}

Now let's move on to inner products on arbitrary real vector spaces. Let $V$ be a real vector space. If ${\bf x, y}$ are vectors in $V$, we write $\langle {\bf x}| {\bf y} \rangle$ for the inner product of ${\bf x}$ and ${\bf y}$. (This bracket notation is standard in physics, but in many math texts you'll see the notation $({\bf x}, {\bf y})$ instead.) We assume the the function $\langle \; | \; \rangle: V \times V \to {\bf R}$ satisfies four axioms for arbitrary vectors ${\bf x,y}$ and arbitrary scalars $a,b$:

  1. $ \langle a {\bf x} + b{\bf y} | {\bf z} \rangle = a \langle {\bf x} | {\bf z}\rangle + b \langle{\bf y} | {\bf z}\rangle$. This is called linearity in the first factor.
  2. $\langle {\bf x} |a {\bf y} + b{\bf z} \rangle = a \langle {\bf x} | {\bf y}\rangle + b \langle{\bf x} | {\bf z}\rangle$. This is called linearity in the second factor.
  3. $\langle {\bf x} | {\bf y}\rangle = \langle {\bf y} | {\bf x}\rangle$. This is called symmetry.
  4. If ${\bf x} \ne 0$, then $\langle {\bf x} | {\bf x} \rangle > 0$. This is called positivity. We then define $|{\bf x}|$ to be $\sqrt{\langle {\bf x}|{\bf x} \rangle}$.
The most common examples are:
  1. $V = {\bf R}^n$ and $\langle {\bf x} | {\bf y} \rangle = {\bf x}^T {\bf y} = \sum_i x_i y_i$. This is called the standard inner product on ${\bf R}^n$. There are plenty of other inner products that satisfy the axioms, but this is the simplest.
  2. $V$ is a space of functions, say on the interval $[0,1]$, and $\langle f | g \rangle = \int_0^1 f(t) g(t) dt$. This is called the $L^2$ inner product. It comes up a lot in quantum mechanics.
  3. $V$ is a space of $n \times m$ matrices, and $\langle A | B \rangle = Tr(A^T B)$. Note that the standard inner product on ${\bf R}^n$ is a special case of this with $m=1$.

No matter what $V$ is, and no matter what the inner product is, we can derive certain properties from the axioms. The most important is the Schwarz inequality: $$|\langle {\bf x}| {\bf y} \rangle | \le |{\bf x}|\, |{\bf y}|.$$ This allows us to define the angle between two vectors to be the angle whose cosine is $\frac{\langle {\bf x}|{\bf y}\rangle}{|{\bf x}|\, |{\bf y}|}$. This brings us back, full circle, to $|{\bf x}|\, |{\bf y}| \cos(\theta)$. Only now we can speak about the angle between two functions, or between two matrices, as well as the angle between two vectors in ${\bf R}^3$.

Real inner products and the Schwarz inequality are explained in the following video: